Why Could Your Social Security Suddenly Drop by 25.5% After Giving Up a Green Card?

Giving up a U.S. green card does not mean losing Social Security, but it can change a retiree’s U.S. tax status. If the retiree becomes a nonresident alien subject to the applicable withholding rules and no treaty exemption applies, the United States withholds tax at 30% on 85% of Social Security benefits—effectively 25.5% of the gross benefit.